The
great thing about my copy of 'The Science Fiction Hall of Fame (Volume
One, 1929-1964)' is that, with some quick short story reading, I can say
that I've read at least one story by a golden age sci-fi writer. I still
have a lot of reading to do but the gaps are being filled in a little
bit at a time…
A.E.
van Vogt is one of those authors that I have never read… until now :o)
My copy of 'Earth's Last Fortress' is hiding somewhere in the study
(despite the bookshelf culling that has been ongoing this week) so I thought I'd give 'The Weapon Shop' a go instead.
I always feel like it's somehow my fault if a story by a 'classic sci-fi' writer doesn't work for me; like everyone else has spotted what made the story great and I'm the odd one out. You guessed it, 'The Weapon Shop' didn't work for me, not at all. While I liked the exploration of the cycle of tyranny and democracy (and how we rail against a system of leadership that we are ultimately responsible for) it felt awfully rushed and squeezed into too small a space; like an outline for a much longer work. Funnily enough, 'The Weapon Shops of Isher' novel was born out of the merging of this short story and two others. I find myself with no urge to read it though, not if the characters are as one dimensional as they were here - there to illustrate Vogt's points rather than have any agency of their own.
I read it back in the 70s, loved it, and the sequel. Read them both a few time many decades ago. I re-read it again about 2 years ago and couldn't for the life of me work out what I had seen in them. I struggled to finish the 120 odd pages. It's the first book I've re-read from my teens that disappointed me so much.
ReplyDelete